My friend Julie Jacobson wrote a piece in CE Pro magazine about her interview with Dave Mayne of Resolution Products about three standards competing for wireless domination. Today’s article features my response.
Bluetooth versus ZigBee and Z-Wave
Anyone working with wireless networks, medical devices, home automation, or The Internet of Things should benefit from understanding lessons learned with HomeRF and why it ultimately lost out as the preferred standard for wireless home networking. Here’s a subset of history from http://www.cazitech.com/HomeRF_Archives.htm
“At its peak in 2000, HomeRF represented 95% of the wireless home networking market, and most analysts viewed HomeRF as technically superior to IEEE 802.11 (Wi-Fi). Its adaptive frequency hopping technology contributed to security advantages over Wi-Fi’s encryption, as well as better interference immunity and QOS capabilities designed to carry voice, data and streaming audio & video simultaneously.
“HomeRF initially had a huge cost advantage over 802.11 and was the first to hit the magic $100 consumer price point when 802.11b NICs sold for $250 and access points went for over $1,500.”
My message is that the best technologies don’t always win in the market, and I agree with Dave that Bluetooth will likely win in the end. It has a huge economies-of-scale advantage with so many members of the Bluetooth SIG adopting it and nearly all smartphone companies embedding it. And then there’s the internal SIG politics, with just a few promoter companies doing the heavy lifting and keeping the strategy on track, while an army of adopter companies have access to the spec for free. Capable, free and cheap are powerful enablers.
BTW, I was the Marketing Chair of the HomeRF Working Group during its peak and it’s fall.
On the first day of CES I attended a Digital Health Summit panel discussion hosted by Arianna Huffington of The Huffington Post. To introduce the discussion, she described Americans’ increase in antidepressants, sleep medications, and stress,…
Can regulatory oversight and public policy keep up with the pace of change? Did you ever notice that culture never asks for permission to change? It just does. The pace of change is rapid and accelerating,…
By Stephen C. Schimpff, MD (originally published in Harvard Business Review) Pharmaceutical, biotechnology, and medical-device and equipment companies have been extremely effective at producing innovations that have created major benefits for medical care. But the cost…
Swiss researchers have unveiled a prototype “lab on a chip” that is surgically implanted in the interstitial tissue just beneath the skin, where it analyzes compounds in the blood, and sends results to a phone or tablet…
“Home telehealth” technology promises to be a critical component of providing quality care to the growing number of Americans who need long-term services and supports to “age in place” at home. Home telehealth and related technology…
Smartphones keep getting smarter, and speech recognition apps like SIRI and Google Now are able to learn more about you personally and act on your behalf, even offering information or suggestions before you even think to…
2 Comments
Thanks a lot for this awesome content. Learnt a lot depending on this content. As an electronics engineer, this content helps me a lot. Hope to see more content like this soon.
The Bluetooth and the Zigbee are both very good medium for the data transmission and that you can get that comparison from the help of the Apple tech support for the use of the different devices and all.
Thanks a lot for this awesome content. Learnt a lot depending on this content. As an electronics engineer, this content helps me a lot. Hope to see more content like this soon.
The Bluetooth and the Zigbee are both very good medium for the data transmission and that you can get that comparison from the help of the Apple tech support for the use of the different devices and all.